Sunday, 13 January 2019

Style or substance?

There have been quite a few articles in recent months asking the question of “how to save cask?” Some of these, especially those from across the Atlantic, refer to cask beer as a “style”. But, as I have pointed out in the past, that is incorrect. Bitter is a style; IPA is a style, but cask is rather a whole system of storage, maturation and dispense that can encompass a wide variety of different styles, but is critically dependent on sales volume to be viable.

However, it has come to be established as a beer category in its own right that commands a great deal of loyalty. In the 1970s, many people would identify themselves as “a bitter drinker” or “a mild drinker”, which could include both cask and keg, but that has virtually disappeared now. Cask is not just a delivery mechanism for various styles, and indeed people are much more likely to identify themselves as “a real ale drinker”. That doesn’t mean they will never touch beers that aren’t real, but that if there is no real bitter available they don’t immediately turn to a keg bitter as a substitute. The handpump has become clearly established as a distinctive symbol of a particular generic kind of beer.

The loyalty goes go the other way too, though. Some people identify as “smooth drinkers”, and I have seen people come in to pubs and ask whether they have any smooth. Likewise, the typical Guinness drinker would not see a cask stout as an acceptable alternative – they identify with Guinness as a brand, not with stout as a style.

I recently ran the Twitter poll shown above. Presumably most of my followers, or at least the ones who would answer this poll, are cask ale drinkers, and the results show that, while some do drink non-craft keg ales, for most it is something they do rarely or never. Personally I can only recall a handful of occasions in the past year, a couple in Sam Smith’s pubs, and one in a keg-only free house in a small town in Wales where I had a half of Banks’s Mild. I don’t dogmatically avoid keg beers, but if I find myself in a pub where there is no cask available I will generally switch to lager or perhaps Guinness rather than smooth ales.

It’s noticeable how little cask and keg actually tread on each other’s toes in the marketplace. Forty years ago, many brewers had a mixture of both versions of the same underlying product in their pubs, but nowadays the only ones I can think of are Felinfoel and Sam Smith’s. The vast majority of the remaining family breweries, at least in their own pubs, are all-cask. About a third of the pubs in the country still have no cask beer, but in most areas they tend not to be the ones the casual pubgoer would go into, leading some people to overestimate the dominance of cask. And a lot of keg beers are sold in clubs, which by definition tend to be used by regulars rather than casual customers. Very few of the new generation of breweries produce keg versions of their best-selling cask ales.

Much the same is true in the sphere of craft keg. Most craft kegs tend to occupy niches where cask is absent, typically American-style IPAs and very strong or speciality beers that by definition are not going to sell in the quantities needed for cask. There is some overlap, but not all that much. However, it is not difficult to foresee in the future that a keg American-style IPA, albeit at a moderate, sessionable strength, will become a regular fixture in mainstream pubs, no doubt to the detriment of cask. For some drinkers now, the fact that these beers are on keg is a selling point in itself.

It’s also important to remember that much of the change in market share amongst the various segments is due to customer churn rather than direct switching from one to another. Of course some drinkers have transferred their allegiance from cask to craft keg, at least on some occasions if not all the time, but that isn’t the prime reason for the apparent rise of one at the expense of the other.


  1. Spot on. I'd drink Cloudwater rather than some ropey 3.8% Cottage cask, but I wouldn't drink the keg ale. Not that I can remember seeing many keg ales apart from John Smiths Smooth and (oddly) quite a lot of Adnams Mosaic and Ease Up, though I guess some would see that as craft.

    1. Although Mosaic and Ease Up come into the category of sessionable, American-style IPA which I mentioned. Likewise Shipyard and East Coast. I recently say a Marston's advert, I think in a newspaper sports section, where the highlighted beer was keg 61 Deep.

    2. In my local 'spoons they have shipyard and punk, but the former is at least a 30% more expensive than that any of their casks and the latter is near £4 when all 10 of their cask offerings are less than 1.99, with at least a couple in hipsterish styles from trendy brewers. I doubt it'll put a dent in cask sales there. I know that small brewers complain about low cask prices, but this, I think is why we need regionals; they have the capacity (at least the ones who've not downsized have) to make decent money on these small margins.

  2. Mosaic comes in cask as well, though both it and East Cost are under the Jack Brand label so would probably be considered "craft" fwiw. Adnams do both Ghost Ship and Southwold bitter in keg too which is more akin to what you were describing & you can find both competing with each other (ie both keg and cask) at Newmarket races, where Adnams supply the drinks.

    Greene King also have a keg/cask crossover in Yardbird and of course everyones favourite IPA.

    but interestingly, well maybe it isnt really ultimately, but last time I was in London I visited a fullers pub that appeared to be keg only, all on those T bar fonts, London Pride, ESB, Wild River etc, but also sitting on the end of one of these fonts I spotted Dark Stars Hophead, seemingly in keg only form, which I hadnt realised theyd started doing, sadly theyd called last orders before Id got to that bar, so I never got to put it to the test.

  3. Attacker of the Killjoy13 January 2019 at 17:28

    I want proper bitter. Ergo, cask.

  4. Attacker of the Killjoy13 January 2019 at 17:31

    Adams The Bitter was awesome. Sucks to them they'd stop doing it.

    1. The Stafford Mudgie13 January 2019 at 21:29

      Yes, Adnams Southwold Bitter is one of my favourite beers. I had two pints of it last Sunday in the Holly Bush at Salt not far from me which stocks it alongside Marston's Pedigree and a guest beer.
      Adnams do much Mosaic and other beers in keg which I think they predict will overtake cask in the next year or two such is the disposable income of southern hipsters.

  5. The Stafford Mudgie13 January 2019 at 19:48

    "many brewers had a mixture of both versions of the same underlying product in their pubs, but nowadays the only ones I can think of are Felinfoel and Sam Smith’s" - and in ALL of the Fullers pubs I've used in recent months there have been cask AND keg versions of London Pride, no doubt a belt and braces approach to maintain sales of their top beer.

    1. The keg is presumably the "unfined" version, but it must sell to some extent otherwise they wouldn't have rolled it out.


Comments, especially on older posts, may require prior approval by the blog owner. See here for details of my comment policy.

Please register an account to comment. To combat persistent trolling, unregistered comments are liable to be deleted unless I recognise the author. If you intend to make more than the occasional comment using an unregistered ID, you will need to tell me something about yourself.