Saturday, 6 March 2010

Breaking the silence

There are some interesting motions on the order paper of CAMRA’s 2010 AGM, to be held next month in the Isle of Man. I was particularly struck by Motion 13:

This Conference censures the NE for failing to address and counter the ‘anti-alcohol lobby'. Its silence in the face of a continuing onslaught against even moderate alcohol consumption is counter to the aims of the campaign in encouraging responsible consumption of cask-conditioned beer.

Conference instructs the NE to mount a constructive rebuttal of the aims of the growing ‘anti-alcohol lobby' and a defence of the responsible consumption of cask beer at every opportunity.

Proposed by Peter Alexander
Seconded by Graham Donning
Perhaps somebody has been reading the poll I conducted a couple of months back. I wish them luck with it, but, realistically, until CAMRA realises that it cannot counter the anti-alcohol lobby effectively without to some extent making common cause with non real ale drinkers and at-home drinkers, it will simply be falling into the neo-Pros’ divide and rule trap.

Motions 5 and 16 may also lead to some lively debate.


  1. And me thinking CAMRA was a
    Temperance Movement.Are women
    allowed in the gang or what.
    For the sake of England's pubs,
    another motion
    "That this conference in the Isle of Man purchase a boarded up Hotel
    and stay here.


  2. About time CAMRA takes action on the fake charities run by neo-prohibitionists instead of holding meetings with Alcohol Concern to discuss common ground.


Comments, especially on older posts, may require prior approval. See here for details of my comment policy.