Monday 17 September 2012

Usual suspects

The Beer Orders and the subsequent massive sell-off of pubs were supposed to open the way for unprecedented choice in the beer market. To some extent this has happened but, as many warned at the time, opening up the market would tend to lead in the majority of pubs, not to more choice, but to a handful of popular beers squeezing others out. And, all too often, this is now the case. If you venture outside specialist beer pubs, you are likely to find the same limited range of beers dominating – currently beers such as Cumberland Ale, Old Speckled Hen, Wainwright, London Pride, Landlord, Doom Bar and Bombardier. None bad beers as such, but it’s depressing when you find three out of those on the bar of every non-tied pub you go into. It’s also the case that pretty much all of these are within the same strength range of 4.0%-4.5%.

On the other hand, in an independent brewer’s tied house, you may well find a more balanced selection with a wider range of strengths. For example, a Wadworth’s tied pub (The St James’ Tavern in Winchester) offered the 3.5% Henry’s IPA, the 4.3% 6X, and the 5.5% Bishop’s Tipple. Compare that with the typical “free” or pubco outlet where all beers will be within a couple of points of 4.2%.

Which, realistically, is better? And, as I’ve always said, choice should be found between pubs, not the same choice within every single pub.

The effect is even more marked in the keg sector. When, in England or Wales, did you last see any standard lager beyond Carling, Carlsberg and Foster’s outside a brewery tied pub?


  1. At least non-brewery owned pubs in this part of Kent include Harvey's Best in their selection of beers. (they'd be foolish no to!).

    Apart from that it is the usual suspects, although we don't ever see Jennings or Thwaites beers down here.

  2. Sharps Doom Bar is this decades Landlord or 6X, though not a patch on those beers.

    Agree it's depressing to see such a similar selection in pub chain pubs, though of course these would have been cause for celebration 30 years ago.

    Re; Winchester, what was the selection like in the old-Marstons houses ?

  3. "Winchester, what was the selection like in the old-Marstons houses?"

    Well, as you know they were sold to Greene King. Only to my knowledge went in two - the Queen, which I think had IPA, OSH and one or two guests, and the Hyde Tavern, which is now a free house and had about five beers on, and where I had a very tired pint of gravity-dispensed Stonehenge Pigswill.

    If memory serves me correctly, Eldridge Pope also used to have a holding of tied pubs in and around Winchester, including the famous Wykeham Arms which is now a Fuller's pub.

  4. Why would you want a beer other than fosters?

  5. Why would you want a cheese other than Dairylea?


Comments, especially on older posts, may require prior approval by the blog owner. See here for details of my comment policy.

Please register an account to comment. Unregistered comments will generally be rejected unless I recognise the author. If you want to comment using an unregistered ID, you will need to tell me something about yourself.